Women with children face greater gender gap than the childless

Women face a widening pay gap with their male counterparts once they start a family, a study by a leading economic think tank has found.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) found that while the overall “gender wage gap” had narrowed over the past two decades, women with children were falling behind.

The study, carried out for the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, found that on average, hourly pay rates for women are currently around 18% lower than for men. That compares with a gap of 23% in 2003 and 28% in 1993.

However once women started a family, gap widened consistently year by year so that by the time their first child had reached the age of 12, their hourly pay was 33% down on men.

The report suggested the difference may be down to women working fewer hours once they have children and, as a consequence, missing out on promotions – or simply accumulating less labour market experience – while their male colleagues pull further and further ahead.

It also found the closing of the overall wage gap was down to improvements in the pay rates of less well-qualified women, who didn’t have A-levels or other higher qualifications, while for better-educated women the gap had remained unchanged for 20 years.

IFS director Robert Joyce, a co-author of the report, said: “Women in jobs involving fewer hours of work have particularly low hourly wages, and this is because of poor pay progression, not because they take an immediate pay cut when switching away from full-time work.

“Understanding that lack of progression is going to be crucial to making progress in reducing the gender wage gap.”

TUC general secretary Frances O’Grady said: “It is scandalous that millions of women still suffer a motherhood pay penalty.

“Many are forced to leave better-paid jobs due to the pressure of caring responsibilities and the lack of flexible working.

“Without more well-paid, part-time jobs and affordable childcare, the gender pay gap will take decades to close. We need to see a step change in government policy and employer attitudes if we are to fix this problem.”

A Government spokesman said: “We want to make our country a place where there is no limit on anyone’s ambition or what they can achieve – that means making sure everyone, regardless of their gender, can succeed at work.

“The gender pay gap is the lowest on record but we know we need to make more progress and faster. That’s why we are pushing ahead with plans to force businesses to publish their gender pay and gender bonus gap – shining a light on the barriers preventing women from reaching the top.

Labour’s shadow women and equalities minister, Angela Rayner, said: “It is unacceptable that the wage gap between men and women with ‘A’ levels or degrees has remained unchanged over the last 20 years.

“There is no excuse for this – women deserve equal pay for equal work. There is little incentive for those young women who have just qualified with their ‘A’ levels and are considering university, to see that in the future they will still be paid less than the men they study alongside.”

She added: “I expect a government led by a female prime minister to stamp out such wage discrimination.”

What people on social media are saying

Some people are tweeting their disappointment that the conversation seems focused on female laziness:

https://twitter.com/CantSwingACat/status/768050062777810944

Others believe the pay gap is a myth:

https://twitter.com/ItssJordi/status/768050250644856833

Or that the issue isn’t about equal pay but equal opportunity:

Only 40% of women get promoted to senior management #genderpaygap isn't about equal pay we have had that since the 70s its about opportunity

— Em (@ItsEmilyPoole) August 23, 2016

Many people have asked those campaigners who want to close the Gender Pay Gap to ‘stop moaning’ while highlighting negative social norms affecting men:

#GenderPayGap what about the #WorkDeathsGap ? Certain things just differ for demographics, stop moaning

— Abradolf (@AbradolfLintler) August 23, 2016

https://twitter.com/delislb/status/768048646185189376

If you want to know more, here’s a guide to the Gender Pay Gap from the UK government’s Women and Equalities Select Committee:

Do you know the difference between #genderpaygap and unequal pay? Read our report https://t.co/QkHNmC8hg4 pic.twitter.com/cma8i3fvv5

— Women & Equalities Committee (@Commonswomequ) August 23, 2016

READ MORE

Proportion of females managers ‘high’ in UK compared to rest of Europe but overall gender equality ranks low

Gender gap grows for expected retirement incomes