Government found in contempt of Parliament by MPs over failure to publish full legal advice on Brexit deal

MPs have approved a motion which finds ministers in contempt of Parliament and orders the immediate publication of the “final and full” legal advice on the Brexit deal.

The Government lost a Commons vote by 311 to 293 on the matter in an embarrassing defeat for Theresa May.

The moment MPs vote to hold Theresa May's government in contempt of Parliament by 311 votes to 293#Brexit latest: https://t.co/xMNz3SwRTl pic.twitter.com/O0Q5GT2FYV

— BBC Breaking News (@BBCBreaking) December 4, 2018

Labour’s shadow Brexit Secretary Sir Keir Starmer said it was ‘unprecedented’ for a Government to be found in contempt and demanded immediate publication of the legal advice following the cross-party motion.

Leader of the House Andrea Leadsom said that the attorney general’s full and final advice would be published tomorrow.

Earlier today, another vote on the whole issue being put to a committee of MPs was defeated by four votes.

The defeat today once again signals that the Prime Minister has no majority to rely on when it comes to getting her Brexit deal through Parliament.

The meaningful vote will take place on Tuesday December 11.

BBC drops plans for May v Corbyn debate

By Harriet Line

Prospects of a head-to-head Brexit debate between Jeremy Corbyn and Theresa May have been dampened after the BBC dropped plans to host it.

The broadcaster said it was “disappointed” not to have reached an agreement on the proposals for a debate, saying it wanted the programme to include other voices.

Labour and the Government had been at loggerheads over whether to accept a BBC proposal for the discussion, which was favoured by Downing Street, or that of ITV, which Mr Corbyn’s party prefers.

A head-to-head debate between the party leaders was due to take place on December 9, just two days before MPs are due to vote on Mrs May’s Withdrawal Agreement.

In a statement, the BBC said: “We are disappointed that we could not reach an agreement on the BBC’s proposal for a debate on Brexit.

“We have been clear throughout the whole of this process that, as well as a substantive head-to-head debate, any programme we broadcast would need to include other voices, including other political parties, to reflect the wide range of views the public and parliamentarians hold about Brexit.

“The final proposal we put to both of the main parties was for a head-to-head debate between the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition, followed by a discussion between eight panellists, including politicians, with a wide range of views on Brexit, and ending with further head-to-head debate and closing statements.

“We believe ours was a fair and appropriate format for those taking part and, crucially, for our audiences around the country, and it is a shame we will not be able to bring them this programme.”

The broadcaster added that it would keep audiences informed with news coverage, analysis and other programmes including a Brexitcast “takeover” of The One Show.

The BBC statement came hours after Labour said the BBC’s proposal was a “mishmash” with “a lopsided panel of other politicians and public figures, not a straightforward head-to-head debate”.

A Labour source said the party’s message to Mrs May was “come and join us on ITV”.

On Monday, the Prime Minister expressed concern that holding the debate on ITV would mean she missed Strictly Come Dancing.

Mr Corbyn last week complained on This Morning that the BBC’s proposal would clash with jungle-based reality show I’m A Celebrity, Get Me Out Of Here!

ITV stressed that “invitations remain open” to both Mrs May and Mr Corbyn to appear in a debate on the channel.

“As always, it is up to those invited to decide whether they want to accept the invitation,” a spokesman said.

Meanwhile, the Commons will consider calls led by Sky News for an independent commission to arrange leaders’ debates during general election campaigns.

A petition has been signed by more than 100,000 people calling for a commission to take decision-making out of the politicians’ and broadcasters’ hands and ensure TV debates become a regular fixture of UK elections.

The debate will take place on January 7, but the Government has already said TV showdowns are a matter for political parties and it has no plans to change electoral law to make them mandatory.